216ethnicstudies

Chapter 16

Rowdy Gives Me Advice About Love

Study guide · Week 9Check yourself →

Class-edition pages 114–117. Cite each quotation with the printed page shown beside it—for example, (Alexie 114).

Your aimRowdy says Junior only likes Penelope because she's white. Is Rowdy right?

Read and make your own notes. Turn the highlights on when you are ready to compare. Other choices can work when you explain them.

Printed page 114

Have you ever watched a beautiful woman play volleyball?

Yesterday, during a game, Penelope was serving the ball and I watched her like she was a work of art.

She was wearing a white shirt and white shorts, and I could see the outlines of her white bra and white panties.

Her skin was pale white. Milky white. Cloud white.1

So she was all white on white on white, like the most perfect kind of vanilla dessert cake you’ve ever seen.

I wanted to be her chocolate topping.2

Printed page 114

Printed page 115

She was serving against the mean girls from Davenport Lady Gorillas. Yeah, you read that correctly. They willingly called themselves the Lady Gorillas. And they played like superstrong primates, too. Penelope and her teammates were getting killed. The score was like 12 to 0 in the first set.

But I didn’t care.3

I just wanted to watch the sweaty Penelope sweat her perfect sweat on that perfectly sweaty day.

She stood at the service line, bounced the volleyball a few times to get her rhythm, then tossed it into the air above her head.

She tracked the ball with her blue eyes. Just watched it intensely. Like that volleyball mattered more than anything else in the world. I got jealous of that ball. I wished I were that ball.4

As the ball floated in the air, Penelope twisted her hips and back and swung her right arm back over her shoulder, coiling like a really pretty snake. Her leg muscles were stretched and taut.

I almost fainted when she served. Using all of that twisting and flexing and concentration, she smashed the ball5 and aced the Lady Gorillas.

And then Penelope clenched a fist and shouted, “Yes!”

Absolutely gorgeous.

Even though I didn’t think I’d ever hear back, I wanted to know what to do with my feelings6, so I walked over to the computer lab and e-mailed Rowdy. He’s had the same address for five years.

“Hey, Rowdy,” I wrote. “I’m in love with a white girl. What should I do?7

A few minutes later, Rowdy wrote back.

“Hey, Asshole,” Rowdy wrote back. “I’m sick of Indian guys who treat white women like bowling trophies.8 Get a life.”

Printed page 115

Printed page 116

Well, that didn’t do me any good. So I asked Gordy what I should do about Penelope.

“I’m an Indian boy,” I said. “How can I get a white girl to love me?”

Let me do some research on that9,” Gordy said.

A few days later, he gave me a brief report.

“Hey, Arnold,” he said. “I looked up ‘in love with a white girl’ on Google and found an article about that white girl named Cynthia who disappeared in Mexico last summer. You remember how her face was all over the papers and everybody said it was such a sad thing?”

“I kinda remember,” I said.

“Well, this article said that over two hundred Mexican girls have disappeared in the last three years in that same part of the country. And nobody says much about that. And that’s racist. The guy who wrote the article says people care more about beautiful white girls than they do about everybody else on the planet.10 White girls are privileged. They’re damsels in distress.”

“So what does that mean?” I asked.

“I think it means you’re just a racist asshole like everybody else.”

Wow.

In his own way, Gordy the bookworm was just as tough as Rowdy.

Printed page 116

Printed page 117

Cartoon from printed page 117 of the novel.
Illustration on printed page 117
Printed page 117

Sherman Alexie, The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian · printed pages 114–117. Parenthetical citations use author and printed page: (Alexie 114).

After reading

What happened?

Junior asks Rowdy and Gordy for advice about Penelope. Both challenge the possibility that he values her whiteness and status more than her individuality.

Close-reading practice
Aim evidenceConnections

These are possible notes. A different detail can be useful if you can explain your choice.

Reading practice · Chapter 16

Rowdy and Gordy challenge Junior

Selected sections; […] shows where text has been left out.

Even though I didn’t think I’d ever hear back1, I wanted to know what to do with my feelings2, so I walked over to the computer lab and e-mailed Rowdy. He’s had the same address for five years. “Hey, Rowdy,” I wrote. “I’m in love with a white girl.3

What should I do?” […] “I’m sick of Indian guys who treat white women like bowling trophies.4 Get a life.” Well, that didn’t do me any good.5 So I asked Gordy what I should do about Penelope. “I’m an Indian boy,” I said. “How can I get a white girl to love me?6

Let me do some research on that7,” Gordy said. A few days later, he gave me a brief report. “Hey, Arnold,” he said. “I looked up ‘in love with a white girl’ on Google and found an article about that white girl named Cynthia who disappeared in Mexico last summer.

You remember how her face was all over the papers and everybody said it was such a sad thing?” “I kinda remember,” I said. “Well, this article said that over two hundred Mexican girls have disappeared8 in the last three years in that same part of the country.

And nobody says much about that.9 And that’s racist. The guy who wrote the article says people care more about beautiful white girls10 than they do about everybody else on the planet. White girls are privileged. They’re damsels in distress.11“So what does that mean?” I asked.12

Sherman Alexie, The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian (Alexie 115–116). Selected passage from the course plan.

Try it, then compare

Why does Rowdy compare white women to trophies? How does Gordy’s example connect?

One possible explanation

A trophy is something a person wins to look important. Rowdy thinks Junior may treat Penelope like a prize. Gordy’s example shows that people can learn to value white girls more than other girls.

Evidence to consider

Explain the trophy comparison

Rowdy gives Junior his interpretation of Junior’s interest in Penelope.

“I’m sick of Indian guys who treat white women like bowling trophies. Get a life.” (Alexie 115)

What it shows: Rowdy compares a relationship to winning a prize that makes someone look important. His accusation asks whether Junior values Penelope partly for the status he thinks she brings.

Read in the chapterThemes

Examine a message about beauty

Gordy summarizes an article while discussing Junior’s question about Penelope.

“The guy who wrote the article says people care more about beautiful white girls than they do about everybody else on the planet.” (Alexie 116)

What it shows: Gordy reports an article’s argument about whose disappearance gets attention. This suggests a wider message about the value of white girls; it does not by itself prove Junior’s only motive.

Read in the chapterThemes

Notice Junior’s wording

Junior introduces his feelings for Penelope in racial terms.

“I’m in love with a white girl.” (Alexie 115)

What it shows: When Junior asks Rowdy for advice, he identifies Penelope by race. Race is on his mind, even though these words do not explain every part of his attraction.

Read in the chapterCharacters
Track the people
Junior

Has his assumptions about attraction challenged.

Rowdy

Offers sharp criticism in an email.

Gordy

Uses a reported media example to question racial bias.

Penelope

The person whose individuality risks being overlooked.

Use your notes to build the Aim Response →